Rain vigil not a practical solution
Issue date: 11/14/07 Section: Opinions
- Page 1 of 1
|
I've lived in Georgia all my life and I always try to defend my state, but let's face it - it's difficult amid the shrapnel of embarrassments flying around during the last few years.
Remember when we had three state flags in two years? The argument over the state flag, a major issue in Gov. Sonny Perdue's first campaign, spun out of control and revealed how reluctant we were to give up the confederate emblem.
And who can forget the hearty belly laugh the nation had on our behalf after the evolution incident in the Cobb County school system?
To cap it all off, Tuesday morning Perdue held a public prayer vigil for rain on the front steps of the state capitol. The event was also hosted by Lieutenant Governor Casey Cagle and Representative Melvin Everson along with leaders from various religious institutions.
A public prayer vigil is an inappropriate way to deal with the problems we face from the drought and is a cheap political tactic.
Separation of church and state is a founding principle in America.
Though they often bleed together, we at least try to project that we have a secular government.
As an elected official, Perdue disregarded the principle of separation of church and state by organizing a religious event, and had the brass to do so at a government building.
I firmly believe that religion is a personal matter and always have respected people with strong beliefs. If the governor wants to pray for rain, he has a constitutionally protected right to do so.
However, as an elected official he should do so with members of his church - at his church. Prayer has no place on the steps of the capitol.
Georgia is home to a diverse and progressive population that deserves better from our politicians.
Tuesday's vigil was a slap in the face to anyone who has worked hard to find practical solutions to help Georgia during this drought. Instead of praying for rain, Perdue, Cagle and others need to spend their time and resources on more immediate and realistic solutions to the drought.
Recovering from our water deficit will be difficult, and it will take time to get out of a drought state.
Conservation needs to become a way of life. The state needs to offer incentives to those who install water saving devices, like toilets that use less water and receptacles for collecting rainwater.
There also should be strict financial penalties for water wasters. We can pray until our knees bleed, but only when we come together and work to conserve our remaining water will we be able to get by until the skies finally open up.
- Melissa Weinman is the associate news editor of The Red & Black.
Spring Break

Viewing Comments 1 - 10 of 61
Joe Mahler
posted 11/14/07 @ 7:39 AM EST
Separation of church and state is a founding principle in America.
Melissa, freedom of religion is a founding principle in America. Every person in the States which comprose this federation (confederation) which we call the united States of America is guarantied by the First Amendment to the federal constitution that Congress will not establish a state religion. (Continued…)
Ben C
posted 11/14/07 @ 8:45 AM EST
Sonny may be able to lead a prayer vigil, but he's proven himself unable to lead a state.
Alan Grimsley
posted 11/14/07 @ 9:09 AM EST
There are many points in your article that I will attribute to your youth.
1. The flag flap was not so much that we wanted to keep a Confederate emblem so much as we don't want to be told by outsiders that we have to change our flag because they don't like it. (Continued…)
Really?
posted 11/14/07 @ 11:54 AM EST
Outside of the whole church/state thing, is no one going to mention that the prayer vigil is kind of a dumb idea? Argue all you want about whether the governor should be able to lead a prayer vigil, but the fact is that I highly doubt God is going to be like "famine? genocide? eff that. (Continued…)
Daniel Brettschneider
posted 11/14/07 @ 12:23 PM EST
Melissa, not only do we strive as a nation to keep church and state separate, but it is state far more explicitly in our own Georgia State Constitution:
No money shall ever be taken from the public treasury, directly or indirectly, in aid of any church, sect, cult, or religious denomination or of any sectarian institution. (Continued…)
CoastalDawg
posted 11/14/07 @ 12:58 PM EST
Governor Perdue does NOT give up his own personal rights as the leader of our state. I'm saddened that our country which was founded on the very Judaeo-Christian principles exercised in our state on Tuesday are to be tossed aside by know it all youth who apparently have never had the opportunity or taken time to connect with God. (Continued…)
CoastalDawg
posted 11/14/07 @ 1:06 PM EST
Really? "but to step away from legitimate solutions" - exactly WHAT legitimate solutions do you suggest to get rain? I suppose that you MUST have the answer or you wouldn't bothered to have posted here, right? "the prayer vigil is kind of a dumb idea" - so again, you MUST have a better suggestion, right? I'll be anxious to read it when it's posted and maybe I'll pass it along to the governor - he'll be surprised to learn that you have a better idea than God, I think. (Continued…)
Really?
posted 11/14/07 @ 1:59 PM EST
CoastalDawg,
I have ALL solutions.
Ok, obviously, I don't know the answer. That's not the point. The point is that God is not going to fix our entire drought just because we get some bible-beaters together for a little rain prayer. (Continued…)
reality
posted 11/14/07 @ 2:25 PM EST
I am truly amazed that intelligent people think it is a good idea than an elected official is "Praying" for rain on the publics dime and time. If he wants to pray for rain do it in private and not sending out press releases to he can do it infront of cameras. (Continued…)
Daniel
posted 11/14/07 @ 2:33 PM EST
In related news, Gov. Perdue invited Pacman Jones to the capital to make it rain.
Post a Comment